_Culla vs Narrative Select_

# A Narrative Select alternative with no account and no subscription.

Narrative — the app that used to be Narrative Select — is a subscription that needs an account and copies cards before you cull. Culla opens the card itself, and Smart Cull runs on your Mac. $24.99 once, for your Mac, iPhone and iPad.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6818320656?pt=2269361&ct=agents&mt=8)

One-time purchase for Mac, iPhone and iPad · macOS, iOS and iPadOS 26 or later

_At a glance_

## Culla and Narrative, side by side.

|  | Culla | Narrative |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Price | **$24.99 once** on the App Store — one purchase for Mac, iPhone and iPad | From $10 a month billed annually ($120 a year), or $15 a month. The free plan was retired |
| Opening a card | Right on the card. Nothing to copy | Cards are copied with Quick Ingest; folders open in place |
| Account and internet | No account. Culla never connects to the internet | An account; works offline for up to 30 days between sign-ins |
| AI culling | Smart Cull takes out failed shots, or gets the shoot down to the number you ask for; near-identical shots are grouped | Assisted: scenes, face close-ups, eye and focus checks, optional auto-rating. Scenes and close-ups start with the Standard plan |
| Handing off to your editor | A tag can stand for a star rating or color label, written to the XMP sidecar for Lightroom, Capture One and Photo Mechanic. Or export a tag's photos to a folder | Ships ratings to Lightroom, Capture One or Photoshop through XMP |
| Editing | No — Culla is made for culling | AI editing presets built in |
| Platforms | Mac, iPhone and iPad: macOS 26 or later on Apple silicon and Intel; iOS and iPadOS 26 or later | Mac and Windows; not available on iPad |

### Choose Culla if

- You'd rather pay once than $120 or more a year.
- You don't want an account, or an app that needs to sign in at least every 30 days.
- You want to cull straight from the card, before anything is copied.
- You want bursts grouped and a first pass done for you, without paying for a higher plan.
- You'd like to cull on an iPad or iPhone too, with the same purchase.

### Stay with Narrative if

- You rely on scene grouping, face close-ups and eye checks for weddings and events.
- You want AI editing in the same app.
- You work on Windows.
- You share a plan with your team.

_Right on the card_

## No ingest before the cull.

Narrative opens folders in place, but copies a card with Quick Ingest before you cull. Culla opens the card itself, and photos appear while it's still scanning.

- Rejected photos move into a hidden folder next to the originals, so they stay rejected wherever you open the card next.
- Tags are saved on the card too, and a tag can stand for a star rating or color label that Lightroom and Capture One read from the XMP sidecar.
- A RAW file, its JPEG or HEIC twin and its XMP sidecar always move together.

![Culla's welcome window with the X-T5 card and four folders in Recent Projects](https://getculla.com/assets/m/projects-en-960.158edd4c14.webp)

_Mac, iPhone and iPad_

## Cull on the Mac, the iPad or the iPhone.

Narrative runs on Mac and Windows, and isn't available on iPad. Culla runs on Mac, iPhone and iPad, and one purchase covers all three.

On an iPad or iPhone, open a memory card in a card reader, a disk or a folder in Files, or an album of your Photos library. Swipe to the next photo and tap to reject or tag; Smart Cull runs right on the device.

Tags and Smart Cull's results are saved on the card, in a hidden folder next to the photos. Start on the iPad on location and finish on the Mac at home — the card remembers where you left off.

_Smart Cull_

## Bursts grouped. Misses gone.

Smart Cull analyzes the shoot on your Mac and groups near-identical shots in the filmstrip. It's part of Culla, not a higher plan.

- **Remove Failed Shots** takes out blurred, badly exposed and other clearly poor photos, as strictly as you like.
- **Keep a Number of Photos** drops failed shots first, then near-identical copies of a better shot.
- Show Best jumps to the frame that came out better, and one Undo takes back a whole run.

![Two near-identical frames of an osprey grouped in Culla's filmstrip; the inspector says the other frame came out better](https://getculla.com/assets/m/series-en-960.90a4cf171e.webp)

_No account_

## Nothing to sign in to. Ever.

Narrative runs its AI on your computer too, but it needs an account and works offline for up to 30 days at a time. Culla has no account and never connects to the internet.

There's no plan to renew and no license to check: Culla is $24.99 once on the App Store, for your Mac, iPhone and iPad. Narrative starts at $120 a year on its Lite plan, which doesn't include scenes or close-ups.

_Switching_

## Your next shoot, culled in Culla.

### Open the card

Insert the card and open it in Culla. Photos appear while it's still scanning, in the order they were taken.

### Let Smart Cull go first

Choose Remove Failed Shots or Keep a Number of Photos. Check what it took out in the filmstrip, and restore anything with `U`.

### Pick and hand off

Tag your picks with one key — a tag can be a star rating or color label — then import the keepers into Lightroom, Capture One or any editor, or export a tag's photos to a folder.

_FAQ_

## Culla vs Narrative, answered.

### Is Narrative the same as Narrative Select?

Yes. Narrative now sells Select and Edit as one app called Narrative; Narrative Select is the earlier name.

### Does Culla need the internet for Smart Cull?

No. Smart Cull runs right on your Mac, iPhone or iPad, and Culla doesn't connect to the internet at all — there's no sign-in to renew.

### Will Lightroom see my picks?

Yes. A tag can stand for a star rating or color label, and Culla writes it to the photo's XMP sidecar, which Lightroom and Capture One read when you import. Rejected photos are moved aside into a hidden folder, so importing what's left on the card brings in only the keepers. Or export a tag's photos to a folder and import that.

### Can I cull on an iPad or iPhone?

Yes. It's the same Culla, and one purchase covers your Mac, iPhone and iPad. Open a memory card in a card reader, a disk or a folder in Files, or an album of your Photos library. Tags and Smart Cull's results are saved on the card, so you can start on the iPad and finish on the Mac. Our guide shows [how to cull photos on an iPad](https://getculla.com/guides/how-to-cull-photos-on-ipad/).

### Does Culla run on Windows?

No. Culla runs on Mac, iPhone and iPad: macOS 26 or later on Apple silicon and Intel Macs, and iOS and iPadOS 26 or later.

Narrative's prices and features as of November 2026, from [Narrative's pricing](https://narrative.so/pricing), [FAQ](https://narrative.so/faq) and [help center](https://help.narrative.so/en/articles/7337406-can-i-use-narrative-offline). Culla's price is the US App Store price, one purchase for Mac, iPhone and iPad; it varies by country. Narrative and Narrative Select are trademarks of their owner. Culla isn't affiliated with Narrative.

## Cull your next shoot on the card.

No account. One-time purchase for Mac, iPhone and iPad.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6818320656?pt=2269361&ct=agents&mt=8)

---

Fast photo culling for Mac, iPhone and iPad, right on the card. [App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6818320656?pt=2269361&ct=agents&mt=8) · [support@getculla.com](mailto:support@getculla.com) · [https://getculla.com/vs/narrative-select/](https://getculla.com/vs/narrative-select/)
